Ever Afternoon: A Young Writer Visits Joseph McElroy

After being rejected by almost 40 illiterate American publications, my essay, “Ever Afternoon: A Young Writer Visits Joseph McElroy,” has found refuge in the debut print issue of an Australian publication called Varnish. Literary Aussies can buy a copy here.

My piece isn’t a run-of-the-mill author profile, which is what it would have been reduced to had I allowed the editor, or more accurately the butcher, at the Metropolitan Review to gut and dismember it. Rather, it’s an autobiographical essay that compares and contrasts two writers who are on opposite ends of the temporal spectrum, if you will. Joseph McElroy is a nonagenarian author renowned for his challenging and innovative works, including Women and Men, which Publishers Weekly once called one of the most difficult books ever written, alongside Finnegans Wake. The essay focuses on my meeting with McElroy in Manhattan in 2022, which was a rare and intimate opportunity to converse with the man behind that monumental text. Our conversation touches on everything from McElroy’s many works-in-progress to his friendships with literary giants such as Cormac McCarthy and John Ashbery. Through exclusive quotes from never-before-seen letters, the essay underscores the depth of McElroy’s persistent intellectual curiosity and the overarching impact of his work on contemporary literature. Above all, the essay is a reflection on the bond that forms between a young writer, 29, and a veteran writer, 92, including a bond over abandonment.

Let the following be a digital errata sheet tallying what was introduced into my essay by one of the Varnish editors and shown to me after it was too late to restore the text:

Page 123, BREATHER should be all caps, as that’s how it’s stylized in the book, nor should the word be italicized, as it’s the name of sections within the book, not the title of the book. If anything, it would need to be in quotations.

Page 127, Infinite Jest should be italicized in the fourth paragraph from the top.

Page 128, There should be a break after the third paragraph from the bottom, as that ends the section.

Page 131, “His children aren’t his children but extensions of him, that exist with his consent.” The comma doesn’t belong there.

Page 135, “He dons bright red sneakers, not clown shoes but Hermès-grade footwear for tackling the blocks of the Big Apple.” The sentence is supposed to reference Hermes, the Greek God, not “Hermès,” some French clothing brand I had to look up.

Page 135, The mention of Golden Handcuffs Review should come with the specifics of which issue is being discussed/quoted, even if only in a footnote: Winter-Spring 2011; Vol 1, No. 14.

Page 138, End of fourth paragraph from the bottom: In fact, one phrase that stayed with me was about the wooden horse “excreting Greeks”. Punctuation should always go INSIDE quotation marks. This error on page 142 and page 147, and likely elsewhere.

Page 138, There should be a break after the penultimate paragraph, ending in “among other creations,” as that ends the section.

Page 143, The editor has introduced an error into Shakespeare: “Is’t,” a contraction for is it, should be the beginning of the second question of three quoted in the middle of the page, not “It’s.”

3 Comments

  1. The price of the magazine is a bit too much for me…. I’ve corresponded with McElroy as we shared Dalkey Archive and Long Island, New York etc… his books are monuments that refuse to be tombstones… but but over the years I’ve collected copiers of Women and Men…. i wish he had focused more closely on his experience of Long Island…. which should have been his place….in the back of my mind he had the chance to be a sort of genuine re-incarnation of JJ….. but McElroy remains doomed to disappear rather quickly….even though he is of a great age Tom McGonigle

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks for the comment, Tom. I’m hoping I can still get this essay out, whether print or digital, in the US after the exclusivity rights expire at the end of the year or thereabouts. I’ll of course announce it if/when I do. If you know of any American editors who might be suited to a piece such as this, do let me know.

      I myself have two copies of Women and Men, a signed first edition hardcover and a signed two-volume blue hardcover from Dzanc. I had the Dzanc paperback, too, but sold it. The Ultramarine edition of Women and Men still eludes me (I’m this close to starting my own press to create beautiful books like that edition…). I still have more copies of Infinite Jest than any other book.

      Yours from Greece,

      George

      Like

  2. I am glad you’re in touch with Jimmy McCourt who is a long friend … we share many things and Dublin is there and Long Island and the fathers and the Catholic education —- his much better than mine —- he’s seen so
    Many more movies and has an ear and knowing of music that I totally lack… I think
    I was an altar boy longer than he so I was able to talk with Julian Green who was jealous of my experience in a way only a convert can express… finally very nice in the company of many of the writers who surround yourself

    Tom McGonigle

    Get Outlook for iOShttps://aka.ms/o0ukef

    From: Thomas McGonigle tommcgonigle@gmail.com
    Sent: Tuesday, 11 August 2026 07:47:35
    To: George Salis comment+e38q2wx50l_gb57b3lf1vv7g@comment.wordpress.com
    Subject: Re: Ever Afternoon: A Young Writer Visits Joseph McElroy

    The price of the magazine is a bit too much for me…. I’ve corresponded with McElroy as we shared Dalkey Archive and Long Island, New York etc… his books are monuments that refuse to be tombstones…
    but but over the years I’ve collected copiers of Women and Men…. i wish he had focused more closely on his experience of Long Island…. which should have been his place….in the back of my mind he had the chance to be a sort of genuine re-incarnation of JJ…..
    but McElroy remains doomed to disappear rather quickly….even though he is of a great age
    Tom McGonigle

    Like

Leave a Reply